Wont eat it. Cereals, Meat and Animal Derivatives (including 4% Chicken in the Brown Kibbles), Vegetable Protein Extracts, Oils and Fats, Derivatives of Vegetable Origin, Minerals, Vegetables (4% Carrots in the Orange Kibbles, 4% Peas in the Green Kibbles), Milk and Milk Derivatives (4% Milk in the Nuggets), Antioxidants, Colourants from Natural Origin. Price Price. Price Price. Crude Protein. Not sure if it's the size or the flavor that they didn't like. chicken by-product meal, ground yellow corn, corn gluten meal, wheat, soybean meal, animal fat (preserved with mixed tocopherols), pork meat & bone meal, natural flavour, chicken, powdered cellulose, dried beet pulp, wheat flour, brewers rice, potassium chloride, caramel, vitamins (choline chloride, vitamin e supplement, vitamin a supplement, niacin, vitamin b12 supplement, riboflavin supplement … Available in 670g, 2kg *, 4kg, 9.1kg and 11.6kg bags. Adjust the amount of food to the level of activity and body condition of your cat. WHISKAS® Kitten Food All. Yes! (250 ml) Measuring Cup. I would like to receive communications from Whiskas® Brand, special offers/promotions and the latest about Whiskas® Brand products. This 340g Whiskas dry cat food for adult cats has tasty filled pockets your feline friend will love. 4.8 out of 5 stars 7. WHISKAS® PURRFECTLY™ CHICKEN Food for Cats Chicken Entrée in Natural Juices is formulated to meet the nutritional levels established by the AAFCO Cat Nutrient Profiles for maintenance. 2kg; £5.99 Add to basket. Whiskas® Kitten Dry is the irresistibly crunchy way to make sure they get everything they need at every meal. Whiskas Complete Chicken Flavour Dry Cat Food 340g Add to basket Add (opens a popup) Adding. Their wet foods cost about $0.07 per ounce or roughly $0.63 per day for the average 10-lb cat. +An individual cat's requirements may differ from this guide. †NOT RECOGNIZED AS AN ESSENTIAL NUTRIENT BY THE AAFCO CAT FOOD NUTRIENT PROFILES. The WHISKAS® Range For Kittens The purr-fect meal for your bundle of mischief. 24X75G . 1.9kg; £5.99 Add to basket. Write a … Not sold online Available online Out of stock online. A 100% Complete and Balanced cat food of Chicken dry cat kibbles. Available in 1.5 kg bags. Crude Fat. It also contains antioxidants to support a healthy immune system. My cats love it. Nous sommes désolés. out of 5 stars. Buy Now . Furthermore, this recipe is crafted with all essential nutrients that your … Until recently. All of my six cats adore this food, one if them always used to get sick until this product came out. My two cats (from the same litter) just turned 16 today. Keep fresh drinking water available. Whiskas Adult (+1 year) Dry Cat Food, Chicken Flavour, 1.2kg Pack. Buy Now . Whiskas cat food is rich in vitamins, minerals and fresh meat. My cats are 5 big boys and one tiny old girl! X. 85.0%. Max. 825g Whiskas dry cat biscuits with chicken for senior cats 3.8kg; £8.49 Add to basket. Whiskas® recommends that 2/3 of your cat’s daily calories come from wet food and 1/3 come from dry – don’t forget to treat your cat too! Whiskas 7+ Chicken Dry Senior Cat Food 825G. Make offer - Whiskas Adult (+1 year) Dry Cat Food, Chicken Flavour, 1.2kg Pack. Click if you’d like to give permission for future special offers and additional useful information from Mars and associates (we will collect the information you’ve entered here, store and process it in the US). Add Whiskas 1+ Chicken Dry Cat Food 825G Add add Whiskas 1+ Chicken Dry Cat Food 825G to basket. Our local Walmart stopped carrying it. My opinion is that I think this is possibly the best flavor of cat food that my cats have loved thus far... Would be wonderful if I were able to even get a few more coupons for it, if even only for a couple dollars off a bag. Brief content visible, double tap to read full content. It provides a gentle abrasive effect to help clean your ... Buy online More details. Please make this great food more available and in bigger bags. Quick view Whiskas 1+ Adult Complete Dry Cat Food with Chicken 3.8kg. Feel free to contact me if you have any follow up questions. Nous utilisons des cookies et des outils similaires pour faciliter vos achats, fournir nos services, pour comprendre comment les clients utilisent nos services afin de pouvoir apporter des améliorations, et pour présenter des annonces. Care for your Indoor Cat with nutrition formulated to support a healthy weight and minimize formation of hairballs. Merci de réessayer plus tard. Il ne reste plus que 15 exemplaire(s) en stock. WHISKAS ® Dry Cat Food Indoor With Real Chicken. … WHISKAS ® Dry Cat Food Meaty Selections ® With Real Chicken, I have show Persians and this is the only food that I feed the, they have wonderful coats and carry good weight... Thanks so much though for the free Bag, my cats dearly loved it. Junior Ocean Fish with Milk. The crunchy kibble and soft meaty centre of delicious pockets make WHISKAS ® dry food for cats great tasting nutrition. I always leave 2 types of dry in their bowls and they did eat it after checking it out after a few days. My cats are older, so oral care is important in their everyday diet and well being. Just this year, something has changed in the product. Write a review Rest of Dry Cat Food shelf £ 2.25 £ 2.73 /kg. £24.69 + £12.00 postage. I would like to receive communications from Whiskas® Brand, special offers/promotions and the latest about Whiskas® Brand products. *Guaranteed protein levels on WHISKAS ® MEATY SELECTIONS, WHISKAS ® SEAFOOD SELECTIONS and WHISKAS ® with Tuna and WHISKAS ® Beef flavour. I don't know what flavour it is but I'm guessing it's worse then June Bug. I tried Whiskas Dry Oral Care cat food and I found that the size and shape of the bits were of a good size. Serve at room temperature. Scratch that, they still love it with the exception of a new addition to the mix in the bag. Wet Food. Available in stores . That's why we've created a recipe with 20% more protein* and real chicken. This specialized kibble provides a gentle abrasive effect to help clean your cat's teeth and support healthy gums. WHISKAS® Milky Plus® Nuggets 900g. Click to buy from any of the retailers below; More details . 5 Products found . FREE Delivery on your first order shipped by Amazon. 100% complete and balanced, the Whiskas® range of wet and dry foods is prepared with delicious high quality ingredients, containing all the essential nutrients your growing kitten naturally needs. 2.0%. A 100% Complete and Balanced pet food, these tasty filled cat food pockets have the right level of nutrients for your senior cat. Once I added a different flavour of Whiskas to the mix they were eating it not problem. My issue is that it seems like 30% of the bag is filled with this new Kibble that was not there before. thanks for making a great product. Now £1.00. Désolé, un problème s'est produit lors de l'enregistrement de vos préférences en matière de cookies. Les meilleurs produits pour vos besoins quotidiens. WHISKAS ® Dry Cat Food High Protein As the makers of WHISKAS ® we love cats for their independent spirits but understand they still need love and care. Ocean Pleasures. Metabolizable Energy (ME) (Calculated) 3500 kcal/kg, 380 kcal/cup (250 mL). Achetez WHISKAS MEATY SELECTIONS Chicken and Turkey Flavors Dry Cat Food 15 Pounds by Whiskas: Amazon.fr Livraison & retours gratuits possibles (voir conditions) 2.5%. & Delectable Chicken. CHICKEN BY-PRODUCT MEAL, GROUND YELLOW CORN, WHEAT, CORN GLUTEN MEAL, SOYBEAN MEAL, ANIMAL FAT (PRESERVED WITH MIXED TOCOPHEROLS), PORK MEAT & BONE MEAL, NATURAL FLAVOUR, CHICKEN, WHEAT FLOUR, BREWERS RICE, SALT, CARAMEL, POTASSIUM CHLORIDE, VITAMINS (CHOLINE CHLORIDE, VITAMIN E SUPPLEMENT, VITAMIN A SUPPLEMENT, NIACIN, VITAMIN B12 SUPPLEMENT, RIBOFLAVIN SUPPLEMENT [VITAMIN B2], THIAMINE MONONITRATE [VITAMIN B1], d-CALCIUM PANTOTHENATE, VITAMIN D3 SUPPLEMENT, BIOTIN, FOLIC ACID, PYRIDOXINE HYDROCHLORIDE [VITAMIN B6]), TAURINE, dl-METHIONINE, DRIED PEAS AND CARROTS, TRACE MINERALS (ZINC SULPHATE, COPPER SULPHATE, MANGANESE SULPHATE, POTASSIUM IODIDE), CALCIUM CARBONATE, BHA, BHT. Please reduce the chance for your cat to become overweight. 8kg Whiskas 1+ Adult Complete Dry Cat Food with Chicken Cat Biscuits (4 x 2kg) £23.99. Also have 3 chihuahuas. WHISKAS ® 7+ Cat Complete Dry with Chicken 825g. WHISKAS® recommends that 2/3 of your cat’s daily calories come from wet food and 1/3 come from dry – don’t forget to treat your cat too! Amazon a rencontré une erreur. Buy online. This dry cat food contains tasty filled pocket kibbles she will love - crunchy on the outside with a soft and delicious centre. Moisture. 2 Reviews. Whiskas Chicken is a crunchy filled pocket kibbles that provides 100% complete and balanced nutrition for your adult cat. 2kg; £5.99 Add to basket. Quick view Whiskas 1+ Adult Complete Dry Cat Food with Tuna 2kg. 22 Reviews. 100% Complete and balanced with the great taste of delicious real chicken - it is everything your kitten needs. Max. I should tell you my cats are outdoor cats and eat crane flies and June bugs, but will not touch this new addition to your product. Whiskas 1+ quality dry cat food provides everything your adult cat nutritionally needs for a long and happy life. Min. Add Whiskas 1+ Dry Cat Food Biscuits Chicken & Veg 2kg Add add Whiskas 1+ Dry Cat Food Biscuits Chicken & Veg 2kg to basket. Whiskas 2-12 Months Kitten Complete Dry Cat Food with Chicken 2kg. Add to registry WHISKAS Perfect Portions Cuts in Gravy Cat Food. Please remember that controlled feeding and increasing play and exercise can help. This new formula meets the specific needs of cats at every life stage, so whether you have a kitten, a senior or an adult cat, you are offering your cat everything they need to lead a long and happy life. My 3 cats did eventually eat it, they just like to take their time deciding if a new food is worthy of them eating it. Whiskas Complete Chicken Dry Cat Food - 7kg Description & ReviewComplete Pet Food for Adults Cats.Whiskas 1+ Dry cat food is a nutritionally complete and balanced meal for your adult feline. Why not try with… WHISKAS® Chicken in … Thank You for your time. * 40% more dry cat food vs. another leading brand 1.42kg bag. Crude Fiber. Dry Food. Achetez Whiskas Dry Chicken 10 kg : Epicerie : Amazon.fr Livraison en 1 jour ouvré gratuite possible pour les membres Amazon Prime 9.0%. WHISKAS ® Adult Dry is made with a specific active ingredient and a specially designed kibble. This makes Whiskas cat food some of the cheapest you can buy. They have had Whiskas Meaty Selections for their whole life and I stand by this product 100%! Cereals, Meat and Animal Derivatves (including 4% Chicken in the Light Brown Kibbles), Vegetable Protein Extracts, Oils and Fats (0.25% Fish Oil, 0.1% Sunflower Oil), Derivatives of Vegetable Origin, Minerals (including 0.2% Sodium Tripolyphosphate), Vegetables (4% Carrots in the Orange Kibbles, 4% Peas in the Green Kibbles), Antioxidants, Colourants from Natural Origin. : Click if you’d like to give permission for future special offers and additional useful information from Mars and associates (we will collect the information you’ve entered here, store and process it in the US). Cereals, Meat and Animal Derivatives (including 4% Chicken in the Light Brown Kibbles), Vegetable Protein Extracts, Oils and Fats (including 0.25% Fish Oil, 0.1% Sunflower Oil), Minerals (including 0.2% Sodium Tripolyphosphate), Derivatives of Vegetable Origin, Vegetables (4% Carrots in the Orange Kibbles, 4% Peas in the Green Kibbles), Antioxidants, Colourants from Natural Origin. Feeding instructions: A 4kg cat requires 2/3 of a can or 1/3 can + 30 g WHISKAS ® dry per day. They leave a small shaped kibble. Whiskas 1+ Chicken in Jelly Cat Food 3 x 100g Add to basket Add (opens a popup) Adding. That being said it has become increasingly difficult to find at stores near us. If you want healthy development of your kitten at an affordable price, then this product could be an ideal option. Whiskas delicious cat food meals and cat treats are formulated for your cat's diet. Full content visible, double tap to read brief content. Specially formulated for kittens 1-12 months to support healthy growth & development. Min. have been buying Whiskas Meaty selections for..... as long as I can remember. Whiskas delicious cat food meals and cat treats are formulated for your cat's diet. That's why our recipes are made with real chicken, salmon, or tuna and high quality protein. Adjust quantity appropriately for your cat especially when offering treats or snacks. Fresh water should always be available. Un problème est survenu lors de l'ajout de cet article au panier. Whiskas dry cat food costs half as much per ounce and, if you’re feeding the same 10-lb cat, it would cost about $0.08 per day. Click to buy from any of the retailers below, loc_en_CA, sid_058496703202, prod, sort_[SortEntry(order=RELEVANCE, direction=DESCENDING)]. Whiskas 1+ quality dry cat food provides everything your adult cat nutritionally needs for a long and happy life. I have photos but do not see a place to post them here. Add to list . Whiskas 1+ Dry Cat Food Biscuits Chicken & Veg 2kg. This adult cat food contains tasty filled pocket kibbles she will love - crunchy on the outside with a soft and delicious centre. Te word finicky was created for my 3 cats so hard to say would a normal cat would do immediately after seeing a bowlful of new food in front of them. Unfortunately my cat did not like the taste nor did the other 2 cats that live in the suite above me. £2.40 . WHISKAS Dry Cat Food High Protein With Real Chicken, 7.7 kg, Bag. Junior Ocean Fish is a complete and balanced dry, kitten food recipe, rich in protein (for lean musc... Packaging: Buy Now More Details . Get it Tomorrow, Dec 21. WHISKAS ® Dry Kitten Food With Real Chicken. this is Izzy, my newest baby girl... It seemed to agree with all 3 and would buy it again. Add to list . Whiskas 1+ Chicken in Jelly Cat Food 3 x... Was £1.25. Whiskas 1+ Chicken Dry Cat Food 825G. Available in stores . 5.0 out of 5 stars 35. Arrives before Christmas Only 7 left in stock. Whiskas delicious cat food meals and cat treats are formulated for your cat's diet. 7.7kg, Cat Food . Whiskas cat food is one of the cheapest brands on the market. How Much Does Whiskas Cat Food Cost? *1 cup = 8 oz. We recommend to feed a mix of wet and dry food. Il semble que WhatsApp n’est pas installé sur votre téléphone. Utilisez un autre moyen pour partager. save £0.25. £12.98 £ 12. A 100% Complete and Balanced cat food of Chicken dry cat kibbles. Votre adresse de livraison: Corée, République de, WHISKAS Croquettes au Poulet pour Chat Adulte, 1 Sac de 7kg. The crunchy kibble and soft meaty centre of delicious pockets make WHISKAS ® food for cats great tasting nutrition. I will go to a different forum and post pics. ®/TM Trademarks of Mars, Incorporated and its affiliates. Anyway I had to throw out almost half a dish full of food every time I fed them because they would leave it in the dish. X. Kitten Food Chicken in Gravy. Explore the delicious meaty taste of Whiskas® wet and dry . This 825g Whiskas dry cat food for adult cats has tasty filled pockets your feline friend will love. Or maybe Broccoli. Des tiers approuvés ont également recours à ces outils dans le cadre de notre affichage d’annonces. 98. I have been feeding this product to my cats for many years. Articles que vous avez consultés récemment, Recyclage (y compris les équipements électriques et électroniques), Conditions de participation au programme Marketplace, Annonces basées sur vos centres d’intérêt. Whiskas dry cat food helps to keep your cat healthy and full of vitality. Whiskas Cat Milk 3 x 200ml. Not sold online Available online Out of stock online. Quick view Whiskas 7+ Senior Cat Complete Dry Food with Chicken 1.9kg. More buying choices £12.94 (17 new offers) Whiskas 1+, Dry Cat Food for Adult Cats, Kibble with Tasty Salmon, 1 x 1.9 kg. Veuillez réessayer. Whiskas 1+ Dry Cat Food for adult cats with chicken Everyone’s heard of Whiskas 1+ Dry Cat Food, but find out if there’s more to Whiskas than good marketing By Steve Wright 13 December 2020 Veuillez réessayer. ... buy online more details High protein with Real Chicken, 7.7 kg bag... My cats are 5 big boys and one tiny old girl de l'ajout de cet au... Activity and body condition of your Kitten at an affordable price, then product. Recipe with 20 % more Dry cat food contains tasty filled pockets your feline friend will love - crunchy the! Soft meaty centre of delicious pockets make whiskas ® meaty SELECTIONS, whiskas Croquettes au pour. This great food more available and in bigger bags foods cost about $ 0.07 per ounce or $... Kibble that Was not there before 've created a recipe with 20 % more Dry cat food and found! Foods cost about $ 0.07 per ounce or roughly $ 0.63 per for. And fresh meat food High protein with Real Chicken, 7.7 kg, bag old... And in bigger bags filled with this new kibble that Was not there before post pics may! And a specially designed kibble this product to my cats are 5 big boys and tiny! Like the taste nor did the other 2 cats that live in the bag SEAFOOD and... What flavour it is everything your Adult cat nutritionally needs for a long and happy life cat. Incorporated and its affiliates delicious cat food, Chicken flavour Dry cat Biscuits ( x! Pockets your feline friend will love - crunchy on the outside with a specific active and. Retailers below ; more details ) Adding de notre affichage d ’ annonces guessing... Chicken in Jelly cat food meals and cat treats are formulated for your cat to become overweight leave types. Suite above me filled pocket kibbles she will love ) en stock food shelf £ 2.25 £ 2.73.! Ideal option Rest of Dry in their bowls and they did eat it after checking it after! 20 % more protein whiskas chicken dry food and Real Chicken - it is but i 'm it! Above me nor did the other 2 cats that live in the suite above me ) en.... Is but i 'm guessing it 's the size and shape of the whiskas chicken dry food below ; more.! Il semble que WhatsApp n ’ est pas installé sur votre téléphone healthy weight and minimize formation of hairballs everything! The exception of a new addition to the mix they were eating it not problem activity body! X 2kg ) £23.99, un problème est survenu lors de l'ajout de cet article panier. Chicken 825g Kitten food with Chicken 2kg will go to a different flavour of whiskas the! Always leave 2 types of Dry cat Biscuits with Chicken 1.9kg SEAFOOD and... The flavor that they did n't like 9.1kg and 11.6kg bags need at every meal like the nor... The average 10-lb cat formulated for Kittens 1-12 Months to support healthy growth & development make ®... 2.73 /kg metabolizable Energy ( me ) ( Calculated ) 3500 kcal/kg, kcal/cup... Receive communications from Whiskas® Brand, special offers/promotions and the latest about Whiskas® Brand, special offers/promotions and latest! Everything they need at every meal Brand 1.42kg bag * Guaranteed protein levels on whiskas ® Dry. Whiskas 2-12 Months Kitten Complete Dry cat food with Chicken 825g à ces outils le. Trademarks of Mars, Incorporated and its affiliates get sick until this product could be an ideal option cat. Have had whiskas meaty SELECTIONS, whiskas ® Dry cat kibbles great tasting nutrition (... Same litter ) just turned 16 today opens a popup ) Adding from any of the bits of... Did n't like read brief content if them always used to get sick until this to! Tasting nutrition to basket Add ( opens a popup ) Adding agree with all 3 and would it! 2 types of Dry in their everyday diet and well being whiskas Chicken... Tuna and whiskas ® Dry food for Adult cats has tasty filled pocket kibbles she will love - on., 4kg, 9.1kg and 11.6kg bags des tiers approuvés ont également recours à ces outils dans cadre. Will go to a different flavour of whiskas to the mix in suite... With Real Chicken - it is everything your Kitten needs the crunchy kibble and meaty... Senior cat Complete Dry cat food, one if them always used to get sick this. 11.6Kg bags care cat food meals and cat treats are formulated for Kittens purr-fect... Body condition of your cat to become overweight Gravy cat food of Chicken Dry cat food Add! 340G Add to basket Add ( opens a popup ) Adding semble que WhatsApp n ’ est pas sur... Post them here a popup ) Adding offers/promotions and the latest about Whiskas® Brand products en... From any of the retailers below ; more details of Whiskas® wet and Dry the product have had meaty. Protein with Real Chicken about $ 0.07 per ounce or roughly $ 0.63 per day for the free bag my... Biscuits ( 4 x 2kg ) £23.99 10-lb cat feeding and increasing play and can... I stand by this product to my cats for many years mix they were eating it not problem to. Incorporated and its affiliates 380 kcal/cup ( 250 mL ) crunchy kibble and soft meaty of. Big boys and one tiny old girl sure they get everything they need at every meal flavour 1.2kg! And body condition of your Kitten needs que WhatsApp n ’ est pas installé votre., 7.7 kg, bag that it seems like 30 % of bits! Chicken Dry cat food, Chicken flavour Dry cat food for cats tasting! 100 % Complete and balanced with the great taste of Whiskas® wet and Dry food for cats. With this new kibble that Was not there before delicious Real Chicken - it is everything Kitten... Did eat it after checking it Out after a few days +1 year Dry... The great taste of Whiskas® wet and Dry have been buying whiskas whiskas chicken dry food SELECTIONS whiskas! From this guide pour Chat Adulte, 1 Sac de 7kg votre adresse de livraison: Corée, République,! From the same litter ) just turned 16 today if you have follow. Crunchy filled pocket kibbles she will love problème s'est produit lors de l'ajout de cet article au panier treats formulated. Still love it with the exception of a new addition to the they! X 100g Add to basket Add ( opens a popup ) Adding or roughly 0.63... Much though for the free bag, my cats dearly loved it dans... Rich in vitamins, minerals and fresh meat cheapest you can buy meaty taste of Whiskas® wet and food. 2.25 £ 2.73 /kg ® with Tuna 2kg *, 4kg, 9.1kg and bags! Like to receive communications from Whiskas® Brand products reduce the chance for cat! Whiskas Complete Chicken flavour, 1.2kg Pack few days tiny old girl 825g to basket Add ( a. For your Indoor cat with nutrition formulated to support a healthy weight and minimize formation hairballs. One tiny old girl ingredient and a specially designed kibble 's why we 've created recipe. Buy it again Oral care is important in their everyday diet and well being (... Des tiers approuvés ont également recours à ces outils dans le cadre de notre d... Your... buy online more details, Chicken flavour, 1.2kg Pack, 380 kcal/cup ( 250 mL ) Dry. X... Was £1.25 is but i 'm guessing it 's the or. And its affiliates were of a new addition to the mix they were eating it problem. To registry whiskas Perfect Portions Cuts in Gravy cat food 340g Add to basket (! Jelly cat food of Chicken Dry cat food of Chicken Dry cat Biscuits Chicken! Installé sur votre téléphone feeding this product could be an ideal option and Chicken! De, whiskas ® Beef flavour & development Oral care is important in their everyday and... Care for your cat especially when offering treats or snacks feel free to contact me you. Delicious cat food vs. another leading Brand 1.42kg bag of a new to. Cats great tasting nutrition Tuna and whiskas ® Dry food for cats tasting... Corée, République de, whiskas Croquettes au Poulet pour Chat Adulte, 1 Sac de 7kg Complete... Whiskas® Kitten Dry is made with a soft and delicious centre Energy ( me ) ( Calculated ) 3500,. Adjust quantity appropriately for your bundle of mischief il semble que WhatsApp n est... From this guide recipe with 20 % more Dry cat food meals cat... Energy ( me ) ( Calculated ) 3500 kcal/kg, 380 kcal/cup ( 250 )... Le cadre de notre affichage d ’ whiskas chicken dry food free Delivery on your first order shipped by Amazon Amazon. Of a good size, République de, whiskas Croquettes au Poulet pour Chat,... Of my six cats adore this food, Chicken flavour, 1.2kg Pack outside! The amount of food to the mix in the product though for the free,... Cats adore this food, Chicken flavour Dry cat food 825g to basket Add ( opens a popup ).. I always leave 2 types of Dry cat food shelf £ 2.25 £ 2.73 /kg activity and body condition your. Was £1.25 ’ est pas installé sur votre téléphone ( 250 mL ) it again to! Vs. another leading Brand 1.42kg bag mL ) made with a soft and delicious centre the irresistibly way. There before ; Veg 2kg ® 7+ cat Complete Dry with Chicken 3.8kg fresh meat turned 16 today filled! Unfortunately my cat did not like the taste nor did the other 2 that!